Is parking available at the property?

Parking is available on-site, but it is limited. Guests can utilize self-parking, and there is also an electric car charging station.

What type of breakfast is offered and what are the serving hours?

Cooked-to-order breakfasts are available daily from 6:00 AM to 11:00 AM for a fee ranging from approximately USD 4 to 20 per person.

Does the property allow pets?

Pets are allowed at the property with a fee of USD 50 per pet, per day. Service animals are exempt from fees.

What are the standard check-in and check-out times?

Check-in time is at 4:00 PM and check-out time is at 11:00 AM. Early check-in and late check-out are available for a fee, subject to availability.

Are airport shuttle services available?

Yes, shuttle services are available for guests. The details regarding pricing and how to arrange the transfer can be confirmed upon booking.

What accessibility features does the property offer?

The property features limited wheelchair accessibility, step-free entrances, and accessible public areas. However, specific details regarding room accessibility should be confirmed with the property.

Where is the property located in relation to key landmarks?

The property is located in Islamorada, just a 4-minute walk from Bud n' Mary's Dive Center and a 2-minute drive from Florida Keys Brewing Co. It is approximately 4.8 miles from Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park and 6.5 miles from Anne's Beach.

Does the property have a swimming pool?

Yes, the property features an outdoor heated pool, which is operational seasonally. Guests can enjoy the pool during designated hours.

What are the policies for guests staying with children?

Children are allowed at the property. The minimum age for children to stay for free has not been specified.

What are the policies regarding extra beds and cribs?

The property does not specify the availability of extra beds or cribs. Guests are encouraged to contact the property directly for specific requests regarding additional sleeping arrangements.

Amara Cay Resort - Islamorada Hotel

Average nightly price at Amara Cay Resort by month, last 12 months (USD)
Month	Average price
January	$307
February	$404
March	$388
April	$311
May	$284
June	$249
July	$222
August	$176
September	$168
October	$188
November	$239
December	$302

What guests think

At Amara Cay Resort, travelers praise the scenic oceanfront setting, relaxed vibe, and standout pool and tiki bar, with handy extras like the Rum Runner water taxi, a local shuttle, and kayaks creating an easygoing Keys getaway.

Rooms are often spacious and comfortable, but multiple reviewers note dated areas, noisy or weak A/C, damp odors, thin walls, and views that can face parking lots rather than the ocean, alongside limited or inconsistent housekeeping during shorter stays. On-site dining and the tiki bar are popular, though prices are high, service can be slow or understaffed, and beach access is mostly via a seawall and ladder rather than a walk-in shoreline. Expect a laid-back pool-centric stay with convenient extras and sister-resort access, but temper expectations for housekeeping speed, room finishes, and the beach setup.

Facilities

Cleanliness

Rooms

Service

Location

Dining

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Facilities

Pool, tiki bar, fire pits, and well-kept grounds are highlights, with perks like the Rum Runner water taxi to sister resorts, local shuttle, and free kayaks/paddleboards. Some note worn loungers, occasional maintenance issues, and limited beach entry via a seawall.

Related guest reviews

10

Kimberley

Mar 28, 2025

·

Stayed 5 nights

We had the best room with Lanai looking right out on to Tiki Bar, Restaurant and Pool area with short walk to beach. We enjoyed being able to share amenities with the other resorts as the beach wasn’t great here but three waters was very nice!

10

erin

Mar 11, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

The property and room were very clean. All the staff weee friendly and accommodating. Great food and drinks at the bar. They had a free shuttle to take you to restaurants for dinner. I loved that they had sister properties you could use as well.

10

Liz

Jun 1, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Great stay with family!! The location is perfect! We really enjoyed the Rum Runner water taxi that runs daily to the other resorts. We spent the afternoon at Three Waters Resort. The captain’s Jen and Brianna were so awesome on the Rum Runner!! So knowledgeable and friendly! Our boys loved Patrick who does Fish like a Local fishing out on the dock!! He is so nice!! This was our 2nd stay here and we will definitely be back!!

10

JOHN

Jun 9, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Dock – Beach – pool – tiki bar altogether… Soooo convenient! Excellent, accommodating staff! Will stay there again!!!

10

Terry

Jan 11, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

The resort was lovely and provided everything we could possibly need. They had indoor and outdoor dining and bars, a pool, fully equipped small gym, docking for boats, a shuttle service by land and a shuttle boat to their other two sister resorts. They have bicycles, kayaks, and paddle boards to use. There was fishing gear available to rent and for $3.50 a ball you could hit golf balls in the water.. When we arrived they offered us a free cocktail and a refillable water bottle to use around the resort and take with you.Just stayed 2 nights and wish I had booked it longer. Islamarada is the place to be. Wish we hadn't left to go to Marathon. I will definitely return. My favorite place to stay in the Keys.

10

Leigh

Jul 11, 2025

·

Stayed 5 nights

Excellent staff and grounds. Free water taxi between the three hotels a bonus. Will stay again.

8

Traci

Aug 11, 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

The staff was very personable and accommodating.. it was our 32nd weeding anniversary and they had left a handwritten note and a treat in our room… it was appreciated… The grounds were nice and clean with the exception of the water area around the end of the property where the event area is located did have ALOT of trash which was unsightly.. Having use of the Rum Runner, bicycles and shuttle service was very convenient.. The view from our ground floor ocean view room was pretty awesome..

8

Chelsea

Dec 18, 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

Very small oceanfront, not access, hotel with a nice outside beach bar and pool with various beach seating spots. Small but cute for staying here for 1 night.

8

Juliann

Jun 4, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

The pool area and Chase lounges around the pool need to be replaced. We were told they were on backorder. Otherwise the hotel is very nice. The rooms are very nice and updated.

10

Justin

Oct 14, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

This was our second stay there and will definitely go back. The location is great and there is plenty of well-maintained beach area to enjoy. The room was large, clean and updated. However, the view from the room left a lot to be desired. We booked a standard room so we didn't have expectations one way or the other, but the window was located chest-up (bottom half was wall) and overlooked the roof of the restaurant. We did have a partial view of the ocean, but only if you looked out the corner. The Rum Runner (water taxi) and free shuttle were great amenities to have!

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Cleanliness

Grounds and many rooms are described as clean, but recurring comments cite mildew/damp smells in hallways or some rooms, cloudy pool at times, and inconsistent or delayed housekeeping.

Related guest reviews

10

Anthony

Aug 20, 2025

·

Stayed 5 nights

Very clean also beautiful pool area

8

Charlie

Mar 18, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

The property very obviously still had hints of its age as you walked the hallways. The smell of mildew was in the carpet. The second floor had a staff meeting space that smelled like food, and the talking was very loud at different times of the day.

6

Laura

Jun 23, 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

The property is in a great location; the views are unmatched. The grounds are beautiful and well kept. The room was spacious, and the bed was comfy. What keeps this property from being a resort is the housekeeping schedule and not letting guests know that there will be no housekeeping, and no refills on things like toilet paper and coffee, and your garbage would not be emptied. We arrived on Monday, and we drank the K-cups on Tuesday before heading out for the day. By Wednesday, when we had not seen any housekeeping service. I reached out to guest services via text about 9:30am and was told by Christina that since we were only staying 4 nights, we would not receive housekeeping services. I was disappointed and was not informed of this policy at check-in or at the time of booking on Expedia. I then went to the lobby to find coffee, while there I stopped at the front desk and was told I could have a "reset" of towels, toilet paper, coffee, garbage pick-up etc. but not a full service. Perfect, I thought. We went on with our day and I returned to the room a couple of times and still nothing. Finally, we had run out of Kleenex that we were using as toilet paper, so I reached out again to see if we could at least get some toilet paper. By this time, it is almost 6pm. Finally, someone brings us a single roll of toilet paper and a plastic bag with 4 towels in it. That was the extent of housekeeping that we received. Our garbage was never emptied our entire stay.

8

Chris

Feb 27, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Beautiful property, staff was wonderful. Our room was clean and well appointed. The hallways could use a good vacuuming and the furniture in our room and the lobby areas could use a good upholstery cleaning also. The areas outside were well maintained. A beautiful place, just needs a little TLC.

6

Brenda

Jan 21, 2025

·

Stayed 9 nights

I selected this stay based on past reviews which were mostly 4 stars and property photos but was very disappointed when we actually entered our room. The condition of the furniture, upholstery, mattress/bedding, draperies is very worn, tattered and filthy. Daily housekeeping was a towel change, trash empty and a scoot out of the room, no actual cleaning was done. Our sheets were not changed for 3/4 days even though it was needed...sand/oils etc. The boxspring is badly stained and the bedskirt to cover this boxspring does not fit appropriately, never neat or tidy and half covered if at all-no effort. The dresser is warped so there is not a flat top surface, the drawers lean forward & kept sliding open, the hinges on the fridge cabinet door are hanging off, the toe kick is rotten along with the bed base platform. The shower glass and mirrors not cleaned, the floors not cleaned once, the sink and countertops not cleaned/wiped, the soap dish never cleaned/filled with soap mess, sliding doors never touched or the door tracks for years, the balcony glass railing smudged with fingerprints, water stains way prior to our arrival. The water in the shower has a very bad sulfur/rotten egg smell 5 minutes into bathing, awful. No idea if this should be concerning or not. The positive.. grounds, beach, pool, landscaping are beautiful, front and back. The lobby, bar and lounge seating are well done, breakfast is amazing! Shuttle service is awesome-great drivers!!

6

Andrea

Mar 25, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

It’s a beautiful property and the staff is wonderful. The gentleman for activity rentals was amazing. It’s not a big resort and that was a plus so you’re never feeling crowded. We were able to sit at the fire pit one night, the kids played ping pong and we got chairs at the pool/beach. But… they need to gut the inside. So much mold in the rooms and stairwell. Mold in the bathroom vent and rusty water dripping out. Chunks of tile missing in the bathroom. They told us at check in about the game room and found on our own it’s no longer in existence. And the prices to eat are insane. Easily $120 every meal for 3 people. Some food was amazing and worth the price (lobster bisque) but kids Kraft ma and cheese is not worth the cost nor the aweful Cesar salad. Can’t wait to go back to the Keys but staying elsewhere. It’s just not worth the price.

6

Bradley

Jun 1, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

The common area was very nice, but the pool was very cloudy due to many kids urinating in it. The rooms were upgraded, but the quality of the construction was below average. Great location on the ocean side but overpriced for what you get. Will not be back. too many options in the Keys.

10

Kayley

Jul 8, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Great staff! Super clean too

6

Karin

Apr 30, 2025

·

Stayed 5 nights

We were down in that area for a wedding. Several/families staying there. Walked in and smelled like must/mold. (According to all families) phone didn’t work, the safe didn’t work, tv didn’t work (after 4 requests fixing it. Not that we watched it a lot…but it’s the point for an expensive “resort”), no hot water in the sink in bathroom to wash hands or face. Offer free coffee in the am but 2 out of 5 days they were out. They were pleasant at the front desk. Tried to get a different room to no avail. And don’t get a 6 oz coke from the squirter outside at the Tiki bar. $5.00 per cup no refills.

8

Daniel

Apr 14, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Common areas are very nice and ability to use other facilities is a big plus. Some aspects of the rooms need updating and TLC. Cleaning services were poor as we returned to an open room door and room only half cleaned. No explanation from management. A bit disappointed given the high rate we paid.

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Rooms

Many rooms are large and comfortable, with balconies or lanais and nice views in higher categories. Others report dated decor, poor lighting, noisy or weak A/C, thin walls, and “partial ocean” rooms overlooking parking or HVAC.

Related guest reviews

8

Gina

Apr 1, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

We have stayed here before but this time it smelled like we were staying down in the basement. It had a horrible mildew smell that was annoying and unpleasant, but room was nice. We had a ground level Lanai and that was my favorite part and worth the extra so we could sit outside and get fresh air. It had 2 lounge chairs with a small table, and 2 chairs to sit on and the view was spectacular as always. They had activities for the kids as it was Easter and we saw the Easter bunny. There was a man at the dock with fishing poles in the morning and the kids were out there fishing too. They also had an Easter brunch but we weren't able to stay. The boutique had really cute things and they sold quality bathing suits.

10

Paula

Oct 7, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Room was spacious, clean with a great balcony.

6

Linda

Dec 23, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

I booked a partial Oceanview king room based on the pictures that showed up on the Hotels.com website ... they showed palm trees and Oceanview .... my room was on the second floor and my view was mostly of the parking lot ... the ocean was visible but mostly parking lot and the room was above a room that they hotel must have used as an HVAC or laundry service area ... making noise all night. When I asked about the view they said that was it.

8

Jennifer

May 27, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

I was disappointed. During check in, there were 5 people at the front desk yet only one of them was checking people in (she was great) so took longer than it should have. People ahead of me had to wait for their rooms to finished being cleaned despite it being 4pm. I had an ADA room (booked by mistake) and the bathroom was awful. The shower wasn’t deepen enough so the curtain stuck to me. The floor was slopes to the middle of the bathroom so it flooded the bathroom when taking a shower and I ended up having to use towels to create a dam. There was no lid on the toilet and the counter was very small so there was no where to put the dry towel or clothes- esp since no hooks. Also, the toilet paper holder didn’t work because it was hanging by one end. I was shocked and surprised- are all the bathrooms this poorly designed or only the ADA rooms? Other than this- the hotel was lovely. Comfy bed. Pool is awesome. Gorgeous views. Near lots of restaurants.

8

Ben

Feb 22, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Nice sized and well designed rooms. Great location with a good vibe. Lobby music played inside and out 24 hours a day not ideal……..

10

Paige

May 11, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Beautiful property to relax and unwind. Friendly people everywhere. Only complaint is the lighting in the room. Not much lighting. Rooms are large and comfy and the shampoo, conditioner and bath gel are great!! Thank you!!!

6

Erin

Mar 10, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Breaking my commentary into 2 buckets: decor & infrastructure and location. Decor and infrastructure. They have obviously resurfaced the hotel. The lobby has been nicely updated. Rooms have been partially updated. We had a one bedroom suite. It was "eh". Two pieces of "art" adorned one wall, others were bare save a mirror over the kitchenette. The kitchenette had no dishes, glasses, utensils, or lighting and a cheap formica countertop. Additionally there was a space for a college fridge but they had placed one in the intended location that was half the size it was supposed to be and it just looked bad. Minimal color, nearly no " style". And inadequate lighting. Stucco walls throughout that just made everything look old. And the balcony had views of the water but also had a lot of noise from the road. They have a property that is obviously aging and are trying to revive it. The pool is a nice space, as is the patio and bar. They were done well. Hvac is old and we had some challenges with the ac running far longer than when the room reached the desired temp. (could see both temps in the display) Location. The other challenge with this hotel is it's location. There is a sliver of a beach which ends at a retaining wall with a 4 for drop to the water. There are steps into a marked swimming area but they are slippery and is not friendly for the old or young. I would not stay here again nor recommend the property. At nearly 700 dollars a night I expected more.

10

Margaret

Dec 2, 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

Our stay was perfect.. My only complaint is i thought I was going to have a balcony and we didn’t.. My room number was 507 and it was the only one that didn’t have a balcony

8

Lisa

Aug 30, 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

Very friendly and helpful staff. Beautiful pool and grounds. Rooms look cosmetically updated, but hallways must be next on the list. We got stuck with a very squeaky bed and an AC unit that sounds like a plane taking off when it starts and while it runs. However, the great outweighted the small inconveniences.

10

Justin

Oct 14, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

This was our second stay there and will definitely go back. The location is great and there is plenty of well-maintained beach area to enjoy. The room was large, clean and updated. However, the view from the room left a lot to be desired. We booked a standard room so we didn't have expectations one way or the other, but the window was located chest-up (bottom half was wall) and overlooked the roof of the restaurant. We did have a partial view of the ocean, but only if you looked out the corner. The Rum Runner (water taxi) and free shuttle were great amenities to have!

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Service

Staff are frequently friendly and accommodating, and the shuttle team gets praise. However, guests also report slow or understaffed bar/restaurant service, check-in delays or overbooking moves, and occasional unhelpful responses.

Related guest reviews

10

Paul

Sep 16, 2023

·

Stayed 2 nights

stay was great. waited an hour for check-in due to short staff. painting was going on in our hallway but did not mind. everything else was clean and neat. received several text on phone asking if they can do anything for us which we found nice. stay was 2 nights

8

David

Apr 19, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Great access to the joint hotels by water taxi with access to all the resort entertainment and outdoor activities. We enjoyed kayaking and the pools every day. Downsides: very slow service at the bars and restaurants mainly because not enough workers. At the bar it was almost like they are doing you a favor serve you, picking and choosing who they want to serve first. The bathrooms have nice lights but toilets were badly maintained.

2

Alla

Jun 22, 2025

·

Stayed 1 night

Came to the property at 11 AM knew that it was too early to check in but showed up at the front desk. Let them know that we’re here, and we got our wristband. Britney at the front desk said they would call us when the rooms were ready. We had two rooms booked both with two queen beds because we were traveling with kids around 3 o’clock, I received the phone call saying that they oversold the hotel and they had no rooms for us available for us and that they have to move us to a sister property. No compensation was offered not even a complimentary breakfast. We spent 2 hours going from hotel to hotel. We went to the other property in which when we got to the rooms, it was one bed with no couch or anything else for the kids so we had and switch rooms again. We were traveling as a family and had to stay in different buildings across the resort from each other. We were not able to spend the time that we originally wanted to spend together. I would never stay at this hotel again!!! be advised!!

10

Jennifer

Jan 28, 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

My husband and I traveled to Amara Cay Resort for a 4 night stay and were very impressed with the whole experience. The room was very clean and comfortable. The food, drinks and service were excellent as well. We loved the reusable water bottles they gave us at check in, I have never been offered that before and thought it was a smart idea! They also had other great things they offered like a shuttle service and fishing. The beach and pool were beautiful even though it was too chilly for us to utilize the weekend we were here. If you’re traveling to Islamorada for business or vacation we definitely recommend staying at Amara Cay!

8

Carolyn

Jan 19, 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

Overall we had a good experience, but I think we may pay up for the sister hotel, Three Waters, next time. The hotel is updated, but some details are still old and worn, shows the most in the bathrooms (our door was falling apart). The service and food is good overall, but in the details, some servers and front desk folks are much better than others. Property is somewhat small, so I have trouble calling it a resort - I couldn’t just stay here for a week. You have to get off the property to have more variety of meals and activities.

4

Jennifer

Jun 8, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Check in was delayed for about hour and half. Very disorganized at the check in desk. Manager never came to speak with is as it is guaranteed check in. We were told we could hang in the lobby with out stuff. Room was very Average for the cost. Resort prices were high for food and drink. Very disappointing

10

Craig

Nov 17, 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

Very nice atmosphere and hotel. However the staff at the bars and restaurants are VERY slow and lack in customer service.

10

Alice

Mar 18, 2024

·

Stayed 4 nights

We had a wonderful four day stay, and we thoroughly enjoyed ourselves! The housekeeping staff was so friendly and effecient and quiet! Everyone from the desk folks to the maintenance people were pleasant and cheery at every chance meeting. We had a problem with one of our entrees, and it was fixed promptly! Job well done.

8

Karena

Aug 30, 2023

·

Stayed 1 night

Pre check in was great and associate was great but before check in they wanted to move me to lower rated sister hotel because the overbooked.

10

CHRISTOPHER

Oct 3, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

The staff at the resort was terrific. Roberto checked us in and was fantastic. We spent a lot of time at the pool and the outdoor staff was super friendly and provided excellent service. The shuttle provided by the resort was readily available and very fun. We will definitely make a return trip to Amara Cay Resort.

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Location

Scenic oceanfront Islamorada setting close to restaurants and attractions, with easy access to sister properties by shuttle or water taxi. Some mention highway and event noise depending on room location.

Related guest reviews

8

Andrea

Apr 29, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Very nice lobby and pool area. Great service at bar and restaurant. AC in room was a bit noisy. Lighting in rooms was a little dark and the AC in gym could have been turned lower than 75. Staff was very nice, welcoming and always helpful. It is a beautiful hotel.

10

Stephen

Jun 22, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Wonderful staff, great pool, the grounds always neat and clean. The room was to die for. Beautiful views

10

Linus

Jan 7, 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

Great location and great place.

10

Lauren

Jan 25, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Beautiful location within walking distance to some restaurants. Offers a water taxi to their other locations. Great trip!

10

Asaf

Aug 18, 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

Very good location and the pool located on the beach

10

paul

Feb 8, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Quiet, easy to unwind,very nice pool. Friendly staff. Great location

10

Stanislaw

Aug 27, 2023

·

Stayed 3 nights

location

10

Kevin

Feb 14, 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

Perfect location!

10

Justin

Oct 14, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

This was our second stay there and will definitely go back. The location is great and there is plenty of well-maintained beach area to enjoy. The room was large, clean and updated. However, the view from the room left a lot to be desired. We booked a standard room so we didn't have expectations one way or the other, but the window was located chest-up (bottom half was wall) and overlooked the roof of the restaurant. We did have a partial view of the ocean, but only if you looked out the corner. The Rum Runner (water taxi) and free shuttle were great amenities to have!

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Dining

Guests enjoy the tiki bar and some meals, but feedback on food quality and variety is mixed, prices are high, and service can be slow; breakfast and coffee hours/pricing disappoint some guests.

Related guest reviews

10

Yvonne

Oct 27, 2023

·

Stayed 3 nights

Loved the pool and poolside bar. Food was excellent .

6

Connor

Apr 27, 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

The beach area, pool and tiki bar are good spots to hang, but the food is not good. Lynne making lates was the bomb. The chicken and Mediterranean bowls were average. Shrimp cocktail and calamari were bad. The bed and pillows were in line with a 2 or 3 star hotel. The beach chairs need to be replace because they are all sunk in. We got partial ocean view and we mostly looked out to the pink hotel next door and the parking lot. All in all for the price, it's not worth it. Pay the extra $ and stay at Cheeca within walking distance to a lot more restaurants/bars.

8

Thomas

May 17, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Great water front, brekfast for 2 $65., Rooms nice.

10

Catherine Young

Jun 6, 2024

·

Stayed 5 nights

Everything was great. The property was beautiful! Staff was very friendly and helpful. The shuttle service was very convenient. The only thing that I couldn’t rate 5 stars was the hotel restaurant. We only ate there one night, because the food was very mediocre. We had no complaints about the food at the tiki bar by the pool.

10

Lady

Mar 28, 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

Really quiet spot in the beautiful Florida Keys. Food was amazing and wonderful service.

2

Katarina

Nov 20, 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

The hotel was OK, but looks much better in the pictures. Had breakfast and one dinner there, both terrible. Couldn’t eat the food. Staff seemed unhappy and didn’t really care about anything or anyone. No beach. Spend your hard-earned money somewhere else.

8

Karoline

Jun 28, 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

Beautiful hotel, pool area and bar. Good service at the front desk. Dinner was ok, didn’t taste of much, waiters not so good. Kept brining the wrong wine and dirty wineglasses. Breakfast was good

10

Elena

Jul 11, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Loved this place! Staff is super friendly & helpful. Rooms & common areas are clean. Close to many known, really good restaurants. The food at the tiki bar is also very good. Watch out for iguanas & squirrels, they're on the friendly (& hungry) side. Fun to look at.

8

Julie

Mar 17, 2024

·

Stayed 6 nights

This place has beautiful grounds, a lovely lobby and dining area. The pool and pool bar are great and the fire pits on a cool night are perfect. However, the food on premises is mediocre and expensive. The charge for a cup of coffee is $6 or $7. (Although there are free refills). It is walking distance to 2 dinner places and one little breakfast joint. The staff at check in was friendly but overall not everyone was. We would definitely go back, knowing the negatives.

8

Peter

Feb 14, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

The room was amazing with a few exceptions. The bathroom sink faucet was too short therefore you couldn’t wash very well. The shower head was too close to the wall which made it difficult to rinse. I was extremely disappointed with restaurant menus. The food selections were minimal with exorbitant prices. We didn’t eat at the resort.

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Su	Mo	Tu	We	Th	Fr	Sa
				1	2	3
4	5	6	7 $279	8 $239	9 $338	10 $294
11 $191	12 $223	13 $231	14 $225	15 $236	16 $234	17 $236
18 $204	19 $204	20 $206	21 $206	22 $226	23 $281	24 $363
25 $226	26 $233	27 $226	28 $227	29 $233	30 $240	31 $240

Su	Mo	Tu	We	Th	Fr	Sa
1 $231	2 $237	3 $239	4 $232	5 $231	6 $433	7
8 $231	9 $233	10 $241	11 $228	12 $240	13 $376	14 $377
15 $227	16 $220	17 $219	18 $227	19 $247	20 $388	21
22 $247	23 $249	24 $247	25 $309	26 $311	27 $309	28 $288
29 $235	30 $238

Amara Cay Resort

Prices for Amara Cay Resort

Monthly average prices

About this property

Location

Room options

Suite, Multiple Beds Standard View

Room, 2 Queen Beds, Standard Partial Ocean View

Standard Room, 2 Queen Beds

Room, 1 King Bed, Accessible, Oceanfront

Standard King Room

Suite, 1 King Bed with Sofa Bed Standard View

Studio Suite, 1 King Bed Standard View

Suite, 1 King Bed with Sofa Bed, Oceanfront

Room, 2 Queen Beds, Oceanfront

Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa Bed, Palm Partial Ocean View

Suite, Multiple Beds, Oceanfront Lanai

Suite, Multiple Beds, Oceanfront

Room, 1 King Bed, Accessible, Courtyard View, Lanai

Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa Bed, Oceanfront

Room, 2 Queen Beds, Courtyard View, Lanai

Room, 1 King Bed, Courtyard View, Lanai

Room, 2 Queen Beds, Palm Partial Ocean View

Room, 2 Queen Beds, Oceanfront, Lanai

Premium Suite, Multiple Beds, Oceanfront

Standard Room, 1 King Bed, Accessible

Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa Bed, Standard Partial Ocean View

Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa Bed, Oceanfront, Lanai

Guest reviews of Amara Cay Resort

Who stays here?

What guests think

Property Policies

Check-in instructions

Good to know

Optional extras

FAQs about Amara Cay Resort

Considering this hotel for your Islamorada trip?

Prices for upcoming dates