Hotels near Silver Beach, Shelter Island

The Shoals Suites & Slips

Superb

Experience luxury with individually decorated rooms, outdoor spaces, and a coffee shop at this Southold hotel near the bay.

Parking

Free WiFi

Free Parking

Non-Smoking Rooms

from

$196

/ night

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

Exceptional

Waterfront hotel with spa and wellness center, private beach access, and two on-site restaurants in Greenport.

Parking

Free WiFi

Sauna

Spa & wellness services

from

$284

/ night

Private 1st flr apt w/ patio 3 blocks from beach

Exceptional

Pet Friendly

Free WiFi

Air Conditioned

Free Parking

from

$263

/ night

Great for couples

The Chequit

Superb

Parking

Free WiFi

Free Parking

Non-Smoking Rooms

from

$195

/ night

Great for couples

West Neck Guesthouse

Shelter Island Heights, NY

8.1

Very good

46 reviews

Free WiFi

from

$406

/ night

Shelter Island Cottage

Exceptional

Pool

Pet Friendly

Free WiFi

Air Conditioned

from

$623

/ night

Great for couples

A Walk in the Woods B&B

Superb

Free WiFi

Air Conditioned

Romantic

from

$419

/ night

Great for couples

Sunset Beach Hotel

Exceptional

Free WiFi

Romantic

from

$921

/ night

Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach

Shelter Island Heights, NY

9

Superb

2 reviews

Adults-only bed & breakfast with swimming pool, outdoor fireplace, and business center in Shelter Island Heights.

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

Spa & wellness services

from

$420

/ night

Greenport Getaway the perfect blend of relaxation, nature, and North Fork charm.

Greenport West, NY

Pool

Free WiFi

Gym & fitness facilities

Beach (Nearby)

from

$1,013

/ night

Southold Waterfront with Boat Dock, Boat Ramp, Hot Tub & Beaches

Southold, NY

Free WiFi

Gym & fitness facilities

from

$1,398

/ night

Great for couples

Sound View Greenport

Good

Relax at a beachfront hotel with a private beach, seasonal outdoor pool, and on-site dining in Southold, New York.

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

Non-Smoking Rooms

from

$206

/ night

Sag Harbor Inn

Fabulous

Enjoy a seasonal outdoor pool and complimentary breakfast near The Hamptons Beaches in Sag Harbor.

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

Free Parking

from

$250

/ night

Great for couples

The Harbor Front Inn

Fabulous

Enjoy a seasonal outdoor pool and complimentary breakfast near Greenport's attractions.

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

Non-Smoking Rooms

from

$186

/ night

Great for couples

Greenporter Hotel

Fabulous

Pool

Free Parking

Non-Smoking Rooms

Family Room

from

$234

/ night

Faraway Sag Harbor

Superb

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

Spa & wellness services

from

$425

/ night

The Cliffside Resort Condominiums

Superb

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

Free Parking

from

$320

/ night

Great for couples

American Beech Hotel - Greenport

Fabulous

Free WiFi

Spa & wellness services

Non-Smoking Rooms

Family Room

from

$320

/ night

The Menhaden Hotel

Exceptional

Parking

Free WiFi

Free Parking

Beach (Nearby)

from

$364

/ night

Renovated Townhouse walk to all

Exceptional

Free WiFi

Beach (Nearby)

from

$515

/ night