Charming 4-Season Cayuga Lake House near Sheldrake Point!!
From
$617
/ night
Select dates to see prices and availability
From
$617
/ night
About this property
Casa Cayuga is our beautiful Cayuga Lake property in Upstate NY! Modern appliances, bedding and towels are all available for your use. Our dock gets you on the lake so bring your swimwear and fishing poles!Located in the center of NY State'...
Location
Located in Interlaken, this vacation home is on the waterfront. The area's natural beauty can be seen at Cayuga Lake and Seneca Lake. Looking to enjoy an event or a game while in town? See what's going on at Dick Van Dyke Addiction Treatment Center, or consider a night out at Trumansburg Fairgrounds. Discover the area's water adventures with jet skiing and kayaking nearby, or enjoy the great outdoors with mountain biking and hiking.
Pet Friendly
Refrigerator
TV
Microwave
Hair Dryer
DVD Player
Guest reviews of Charming 4-Season Cayuga Lake House near Sheldrake Point!!
9.9
Exceptional
Based on 58 verified reviews
What guests think
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Charming Cottage with great views on Cayuga Lake in Sheldrake is widely praised for its peaceful, lakefront setting, cozy interiors, and convenient access to wineries and hikes, with many repeat guests and constant appreciation for the spectacular, water-facing views.
Read moreWas this helpful?
What guests think
Charming Cottage with great views on Cayuga Lake in Sheldrake is widely praised for its peaceful, lakefront setting, cozy interiors, and convenient access to wineries and hikes, with many repeat guests and constant appreciation for the spectacular, water-facing views.
Guests consistently commend the friendly, communicative hosts and smooth check-in, with occasional notes about exterior security cameras, a day of septic maintenance, and advance notice on drinking water. Outdoor amenities like the dock, kayaks, multiple decks, fire pit, grill, and a fenced yard for dogs are frequently enjoyed, and many find the cottage very clean and comfortable. Expect a tranquil, well-equipped lake getaway close to Finger Lakes attractions.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Facilities
Guests frequently enjoy the lakefront setup with a dock, kayaks, multiple decks, a fire pit, grill, and a fenced yard for dogs. Several note a well-equipped kitchen and extras like a SUP and bikes.
Related guest reviews
10
Peter S.
Jun 9, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Beautiful spot on the water. Kayaks were great, good fishing off the dock, nice grill and fenced in property for the dog. Couple good restaurants nearby and plenty of wineries - all around fantastic stay. We hope to be back soon!
Beautiful spot on the water. Kayaks were great, good fishing off the dock, nice grill and fenced in property for the dog. Couple good restaurants nearby and plenty of wineries - all around fantastic stay. We hope to be back soon!
10
Denise T.
Sep 21, 2024
·
Stayed 6 nights
Quiet,nice,beautiful view, nearby wineries and restaurants that were excellent. The nighttime fire pit was used and appreciated,wonderful moon views
Quiet,nice,beautiful view, nearby wineries and restaurants that were excellent. The nighttime fire pit was used and appreciated,wonderful moon views
10
Stephanie P.
Sep 17, 2023
·
Stayed 6 nights
We had a great time at the cottage. It was exactly as described, and being right on the water was simply wonderful. Our pup had a great time exploring the yard, and we truly appreciated that the fence kept him safe. There’s no shortage of things to do both on the property and in the area. Will definitely return!
We had a great time at the cottage. It was exactly as described, and being right on the water was simply wonderful. Our pup had a great time exploring the yard, and we truly appreciated that the fence kept him safe. There’s no shortage of things to do both on the property and in the area. Will definitely return!
10
Abbey S.
Oct 30, 2023
·
Stayed 5 nights
This was the perfect place to celebrate my milestone birthday! It was cozy and had the perfect view. We especially appreciated that our dog could join us. The cottage had everything you could possibly dream of needing while on vacation. Our next visit will be in warmer weather so we can enjoy the decks, dock, and all the outdoor activities!
This was the perfect place to celebrate my milestone birthday! It was cozy and had the perfect view. We especially appreciated that our dog could join us. The cottage had everything you could possibly dream of needing while on vacation. Our next visit will be in warmer weather so we can enjoy the decks, dock, and all the outdoor activities!
10
Justin F.
May 27, 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
Great views, great location, and great outdoor area. Would love to come back.
Great views, great location, and great outdoor area. Would love to come back.
10
Brooke R.
Aug 16, 2024
·
Stayed 8 nights
Our recent stay at this home was amazing. So amazing that we requested an additional night and it was easily accommodated. The location of the home is perfect for visiting the many wineries along the lake and just a short ride to Seneca Lake. We spent most of our time fishing off the gorgeous dock catching yellow perch and my husband was even able to catch a lake trout from the kayaks on the property. Jennifer and Toby are top notch hosts who are very easy to communicate with and welcome you with a delicious bottle of wine upon arrival. We can not wait to hopefully book this home for our Finger Lakes getaway next year.
Our recent stay at this home was amazing. So amazing that we requested an additional night and it was easily accommodated. The location of the home is perfect for visiting the many wineries along the lake and just a short ride to Seneca Lake. We spent most of our time fishing off the gorgeous dock catching yellow perch and my husband was even able to catch a lake trout from the kayaks on the property. Jennifer and Toby are top notch hosts who are very easy to communicate with and welcome you with a delicious bottle of wine upon arrival. We can not wait to hopefully book this home for our Finger Lakes getaway next year.
8
Apikanya M.
Aug 16, 2023
·
Stayed 7 nights
The cottage is really cute and clean. The inside is bright and airy. The kitchen is big and has enough space to move around. It's equipped with almost everything you need for your stay including kayaks and SUP board and several pairs of water shoes! (although we wish that there is another comfortable loveseat in the room and the TV is a bit bigger) The double decks outside and the outdoor area are lovely to hangout. It gives the impression that we can have friends over to swim and hangout during the day. It looks like a fun spot to have a cocktail and watching sunset with friends. However, the house policy is not permit over 4 people. So, keep that in mind if you plan to have some visitors. The location of this property is the prime! the street is quiet and is great for cycling, running, or walk. We even saw an eagle perching on the nearby tree! We are cyclists, so we brought our own bikes, but the property also has 2 bikes for guests to use. There's a really good farm stand just a few minutes away and Sheldrakes winery and Ol' Mally restaurant &Cayuga Shoreline (with a fun porch bar) are only a mile away.
The cottage is really cute and clean. The inside is bright and airy. The kitchen is big and has enough space to move around. It's equipped with almost everything you need for your stay including kayaks and SUP board and several pairs of water shoes! (although we wish that there is another comfortable loveseat in the room and the TV is a bit bigger) The double decks outside and the outdoor area are lovely to hangout. It gives the impression that we can have friends over to swim and hangout during the day. It looks like a fun spot to have a cocktail and watching sunset with friends. However, the house policy is not permit over 4 people. So, keep that in mind if you plan to have some visitors. The location of this property is the prime! the street is quiet and is great for cycling, running, or walk. We even saw an eagle perching on the nearby tree! We are cyclists, so we brought our own bikes, but the property also has 2 bikes for guests to use. There's a really good farm stand just a few minutes away and Sheldrakes winery and Ol' Mally restaurant &Cayuga Shoreline (with a fun porch bar) are only a mile away.
10
cindy f.
Jul 30, 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Such a perfect setting. Felt like I was sleeping on the lake . The cottage is so clean, quaint, cozy. Deck off the living area and on lake level plus fire pit area. Totally enjoyed our stay.
Such a perfect setting. Felt like I was sleeping on the lake . The cottage is so clean, quaint, cozy. Deck off the living area and on lake level plus fire pit area. Totally enjoyed our stay.
10
James S.
Sep 10, 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Awesome, very relaxing, the decks were utilized for sitting with morning coffee and listening to the gentle waves crashing. Our dog enjoyed the birds and ducks floating by. It’s so cute and quiet and just what we needed to get away. We enjoy visiting many wineries in the area. Recommend this place!
Awesome, very relaxing, the decks were utilized for sitting with morning coffee and listening to the gentle waves crashing. Our dog enjoyed the birds and ducks floating by. It’s so cute and quiet and just what we needed to get away. We enjoy visiting many wineries in the area. Recommend this place!
10
Jeannine L.
Sep 9, 2023
·
Stayed 5 nights
My husband and I stayed here for our honeymoon. We had such a great time! The cottage is so clean which was our first impression. We spent our week soaking up the sun right on the deck. The kayaks and stand up paddle board were a lot of fun to use and travel down the lake with. We grilled every night! And they have all the cooking essentials you will need. Jen was easy to get in contact with, we had a question about the lock on the door and she called us within a minute to answer our question. The last day we stopped at Taughannock Falls for a walk with our dog Remi and then we stopped at the Sheldrake Point Winery. We recommend both! The cottage was perfect for our dog and since it was all fenced in we didn’t have to worry about him getting out. All in all we had a wonderful time and would definitely book again!
My husband and I stayed here for our honeymoon. We had such a great time! The cottage is so clean which was our first impression. We spent our week soaking up the sun right on the deck. The kayaks and stand up paddle board were a lot of fun to use and travel down the lake with. We grilled every night! And they have all the cooking essentials you will need. Jen was easy to get in contact with, we had a question about the lock on the door and she called us within a minute to answer our question. The last day we stopped at Taughannock Falls for a walk with our dog Remi and then we stopped at the Sheldrake Point Winery. We recommend both! The cottage was perfect for our dog and since it was all fenced in we didn’t have to worry about him getting out. All in all we had a wonderful time and would definitely book again!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Cleanliness
Reviews repeatedly describe the cottage as very clean and well kept.
Related guest reviews
10
Connie P.
Aug 7, 2023
·
Stayed 6 nights
Place was cute and very clean!!! Bed comfy. Location and water/deck/fire pit areas were fantastic!!! Looking forward to returning in the future. One suggestion is the small tv is on a stand in the kitchen/dining table open area and couch is facing the other way...maybe if possible move tv so if you sit on the couch you can comfortably watch. Thank you.
Place was cute and very clean!!! Bed comfy. Location and water/deck/fire pit areas were fantastic!!! Looking forward to returning in the future. One suggestion is the small tv is on a stand in the kitchen/dining table open area and couch is facing the other way...maybe if possible move tv so if you sit on the couch you can comfortably watch. Thank you.
10
Rob U.
Sep 28, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
Great location. Everything was clean. Loved it. Cant wait to return.
Great location. Everything was clean. Loved it. Cant wait to return.
10
Sara W.
Oct 23, 2023
·
Stayed 5 nights
This is the second time we stayed at the property and had another wonderful time! Cottage is very clean and cozy. Great location to hiking and wineries.
This is the second time we stayed at the property and had another wonderful time! Cottage is very clean and cozy. Great location to hiking and wineries.
8
Apikanya M.
Aug 16, 2023
·
Stayed 7 nights
The cottage is really cute and clean. The inside is bright and airy. The kitchen is big and has enough space to move around. It's equipped with almost everything you need for your stay including kayaks and SUP board and several pairs of water shoes! (although we wish that there is another comfortable loveseat in the room and the TV is a bit bigger) The double decks outside and the outdoor area are lovely to hangout. It gives the impression that we can have friends over to swim and hangout during the day. It looks like a fun spot to have a cocktail and watching sunset with friends. However, the house policy is not permit over 4 people. So, keep that in mind if you plan to have some visitors. The location of this property is the prime! the street is quiet and is great for cycling, running, or walk. We even saw an eagle perching on the nearby tree! We are cyclists, so we brought our own bikes, but the property also has 2 bikes for guests to use. There's a really good farm stand just a few minutes away and Sheldrakes winery and Ol' Mally restaurant &Cayuga Shoreline (with a fun porch bar) are only a mile away.
The cottage is really cute and clean. The inside is bright and airy. The kitchen is big and has enough space to move around. It's equipped with almost everything you need for your stay including kayaks and SUP board and several pairs of water shoes! (although we wish that there is another comfortable loveseat in the room and the TV is a bit bigger) The double decks outside and the outdoor area are lovely to hangout. It gives the impression that we can have friends over to swim and hangout during the day. It looks like a fun spot to have a cocktail and watching sunset with friends. However, the house policy is not permit over 4 people. So, keep that in mind if you plan to have some visitors. The location of this property is the prime! the street is quiet and is great for cycling, running, or walk. We even saw an eagle perching on the nearby tree! We are cyclists, so we brought our own bikes, but the property also has 2 bikes for guests to use. There's a really good farm stand just a few minutes away and Sheldrakes winery and Ol' Mally restaurant &Cayuga Shoreline (with a fun porch bar) are only a mile away.
8
Sueanne P.
Aug 12, 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Very nice cottage right on the water. Quiet, peaceful and very clean. Everything you could need was available. There are many venues to hear all types of music within 15-20 miles in the afternoon and early evening.
Very nice cottage right on the water. Quiet, peaceful and very clean. Everything you could need was available. There are many venues to hear all types of music within 15-20 miles in the afternoon and early evening.
10
cindy f.
Jul 30, 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Such a perfect setting. Felt like I was sleeping on the lake . The cottage is so clean, quaint, cozy. Deck off the living area and on lake level plus fire pit area. Totally enjoyed our stay.
Such a perfect setting. Felt like I was sleeping on the lake . The cottage is so clean, quaint, cozy. Deck off the living area and on lake level plus fire pit area. Totally enjoyed our stay.
10
Jeannine L.
Sep 9, 2023
·
Stayed 5 nights
My husband and I stayed here for our honeymoon. We had such a great time! The cottage is so clean which was our first impression. We spent our week soaking up the sun right on the deck. The kayaks and stand up paddle board were a lot of fun to use and travel down the lake with. We grilled every night! And they have all the cooking essentials you will need. Jen was easy to get in contact with, we had a question about the lock on the door and she called us within a minute to answer our question. The last day we stopped at Taughannock Falls for a walk with our dog Remi and then we stopped at the Sheldrake Point Winery. We recommend both! The cottage was perfect for our dog and since it was all fenced in we didn’t have to worry about him getting out. All in all we had a wonderful time and would definitely book again!
My husband and I stayed here for our honeymoon. We had such a great time! The cottage is so clean which was our first impression. We spent our week soaking up the sun right on the deck. The kayaks and stand up paddle board were a lot of fun to use and travel down the lake with. We grilled every night! And they have all the cooking essentials you will need. Jen was easy to get in contact with, we had a question about the lock on the door and she called us within a minute to answer our question. The last day we stopped at Taughannock Falls for a walk with our dog Remi and then we stopped at the Sheldrake Point Winery. We recommend both! The cottage was perfect for our dog and since it was all fenced in we didn’t have to worry about him getting out. All in all we had a wonderful time and would definitely book again!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Rooms
Rooms are cozy with very comfortable beds and wide lake views, and the setting feels quiet and restful. A couple of comments mention a small or awkwardly placed TV and a desire for additional seating.
Related guest reviews
10
Connie P.
Aug 7, 2023
·
Stayed 6 nights
Place was cute and very clean!!! Bed comfy. Location and water/deck/fire pit areas were fantastic!!! Looking forward to returning in the future. One suggestion is the small tv is on a stand in the kitchen/dining table open area and couch is facing the other way...maybe if possible move tv so if you sit on the couch you can comfortably watch. Thank you.
Place was cute and very clean!!! Bed comfy. Location and water/deck/fire pit areas were fantastic!!! Looking forward to returning in the future. One suggestion is the small tv is on a stand in the kitchen/dining table open area and couch is facing the other way...maybe if possible move tv so if you sit on the couch you can comfortably watch. Thank you.
10
Denise T.
Sep 21, 2024
·
Stayed 6 nights
Quiet,nice,beautiful view, nearby wineries and restaurants that were excellent. The nighttime fire pit was used and appreciated,wonderful moon views
Quiet,nice,beautiful view, nearby wineries and restaurants that were excellent. The nighttime fire pit was used and appreciated,wonderful moon views
10
laura c.
Sep 28, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
This cottage is situated right on the water. We really enjoyed waking to the sound of the waves. So scenic. Easy to find. Very cozy. We had everything we needed. And thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Our hosts Jen and Toby kindly checked in on us via text. Very hospitable.
This cottage is situated right on the water. We really enjoyed waking to the sound of the waves. So scenic. Easy to find. Very cozy. We had everything we needed. And thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Our hosts Jen and Toby kindly checked in on us via text. Very hospitable.
10
Terri L.
Oct 4, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
This was the perfect lake cottage with lake views from every window! We will be back!
This was the perfect lake cottage with lake views from every window! We will be back!
10
Justin F.
May 27, 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
Great views, great location, and great outdoor area. Would love to come back.
Great views, great location, and great outdoor area. Would love to come back.
8
Apikanya M.
Aug 16, 2023
·
Stayed 7 nights
The cottage is really cute and clean. The inside is bright and airy. The kitchen is big and has enough space to move around. It's equipped with almost everything you need for your stay including kayaks and SUP board and several pairs of water shoes! (although we wish that there is another comfortable loveseat in the room and the TV is a bit bigger) The double decks outside and the outdoor area are lovely to hangout. It gives the impression that we can have friends over to swim and hangout during the day. It looks like a fun spot to have a cocktail and watching sunset with friends. However, the house policy is not permit over 4 people. So, keep that in mind if you plan to have some visitors. The location of this property is the prime! the street is quiet and is great for cycling, running, or walk. We even saw an eagle perching on the nearby tree! We are cyclists, so we brought our own bikes, but the property also has 2 bikes for guests to use. There's a really good farm stand just a few minutes away and Sheldrakes winery and Ol' Mally restaurant &Cayuga Shoreline (with a fun porch bar) are only a mile away.
The cottage is really cute and clean. The inside is bright and airy. The kitchen is big and has enough space to move around. It's equipped with almost everything you need for your stay including kayaks and SUP board and several pairs of water shoes! (although we wish that there is another comfortable loveseat in the room and the TV is a bit bigger) The double decks outside and the outdoor area are lovely to hangout. It gives the impression that we can have friends over to swim and hangout during the day. It looks like a fun spot to have a cocktail and watching sunset with friends. However, the house policy is not permit over 4 people. So, keep that in mind if you plan to have some visitors. The location of this property is the prime! the street is quiet and is great for cycling, running, or walk. We even saw an eagle perching on the nearby tree! We are cyclists, so we brought our own bikes, but the property also has 2 bikes for guests to use. There's a really good farm stand just a few minutes away and Sheldrakes winery and Ol' Mally restaurant &Cayuga Shoreline (with a fun porch bar) are only a mile away.
10
Lisa W.
Sep 29, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
The lake cabin was so cute & cozy! Bed was SUPER comfortable from the time you got in it to the time you got up. The view is spectacular, can't get any better & the cabin has everything you need. Was great to have a fire and a glass wine by the lake & to listen to the waves coming in on the shore. Owner was great & readily available to answer any questions...I would highly recommend this wonderful & special lake cabin & we would definitely come back to stay again..
The lake cabin was so cute & cozy! Bed was SUPER comfortable from the time you got in it to the time you got up. The view is spectacular, can't get any better & the cabin has everything you need. Was great to have a fire and a glass wine by the lake & to listen to the waves coming in on the shore. Owner was great & readily available to answer any questions...I would highly recommend this wonderful & special lake cabin & we would definitely come back to stay again..
10
cindy f.
Jul 30, 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Such a perfect setting. Felt like I was sleeping on the lake . The cottage is so clean, quaint, cozy. Deck off the living area and on lake level plus fire pit area. Totally enjoyed our stay.
Such a perfect setting. Felt like I was sleeping on the lake . The cottage is so clean, quaint, cozy. Deck off the living area and on lake level plus fire pit area. Totally enjoyed our stay.
10
Melissa A.
Jun 25, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
My husband and I really enjoyed our stay! The hosts were very kind and communicated well for a seamless experience! They thought of everything, so it really felt like a home away from home, just more peaceful and with a breathtaking view of the lake! We took the kayaks out one morning, it was so serene, all you could hear were the birds. We saw some cool birds like an osprey and a momma duck with her babies! We feel so lucky to have found this place. Absolutely would recommend for a quiet, relaxing get away.
My husband and I really enjoyed our stay! The hosts were very kind and communicated well for a seamless experience! They thought of everything, so it really felt like a home away from home, just more peaceful and with a breathtaking view of the lake! We took the kayaks out one morning, it was so serene, all you could hear were the birds. We saw some cool birds like an osprey and a momma duck with her babies! We feel so lucky to have found this place. Absolutely would recommend for a quiet, relaxing get away.
10
Mike B.
Oct 26, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Perfect location on the lake where you could watch the sunrise every morning. Close to many wineries, hikes, and Ithaca. Perfect for anniversary getaway.
Perfect location on the lake where you could watch the sunrise every morning. Close to many wineries, hikes, and Ithaca. Perfect for anniversary getaway.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Service
Hosts Jen and Toby are praised as friendly, responsive, and accommodating, with easy check-in and thoughtful touches like welcome wine and bottled water. A few guests note exterior security cameras, a day of septic maintenance, or wanting clearer notice about drinking water.
Related guest reviews
10
deborah q.
Sep 15, 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Lovely and peaceful stay. Jen and Toby are the best. So ready to help at all stages of our visit. This was our second stay but won’t be the last.
Lovely and peaceful stay. Jen and Toby are the best. So ready to help at all stages of our visit. This was our second stay but won’t be the last.
10
Terri L.
Sep 30, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Other than septic maintenance inconveniences one day…..we loved it!
Other than septic maintenance inconveniences one day…..we loved it!
10
Md25sing
Jun 24, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
My husband and I had a great weekend. Location was perfect and close to so many places. We've been to the finger lakes many times and always enjoy it. The property was great, I will say we would have loved a heads up about the drinking water situation, but do appreciate that some bottled water was left for us. We were also a little turned off by the outside security cameras. Completely understand the one at the front door, but the one over the back deck/private areas seemed a bit of an invasion of privacy, and these were not disclosed in the listing. But overall, still an excellent stay, and would go back.
My husband and I had a great weekend. Location was perfect and close to so many places. We've been to the finger lakes many times and always enjoy it. The property was great, I will say we would have loved a heads up about the drinking water situation, but do appreciate that some bottled water was left for us. We were also a little turned off by the outside security cameras. Completely understand the one at the front door, but the one over the back deck/private areas seemed a bit of an invasion of privacy, and these were not disclosed in the listing. But overall, still an excellent stay, and would go back.
10
laura c.
Sep 28, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
This cottage is situated right on the water. We really enjoyed waking to the sound of the waves. So scenic. Easy to find. Very cozy. We had everything we needed. And thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Our hosts Jen and Toby kindly checked in on us via text. Very hospitable.
This cottage is situated right on the water. We really enjoyed waking to the sound of the waves. So scenic. Easy to find. Very cozy. We had everything we needed. And thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Our hosts Jen and Toby kindly checked in on us via text. Very hospitable.
10
Diane R.
Jul 31, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
We had a great stay at this cute little cottage on the lake. Check in was seamless with all information provided well in advance. Well equipped kitchen as we ate in each night. We loved being on the water and enjoying the peaceful lake. The location was great for visiting both Seneca and Cayuga lakes. Highly recommend Taughannock Falls and Watkins Glen!
We had a great stay at this cute little cottage on the lake. Check in was seamless with all information provided well in advance. Well equipped kitchen as we ate in each night. We loved being on the water and enjoying the peaceful lake. The location was great for visiting both Seneca and Cayuga lakes. Highly recommend Taughannock Falls and Watkins Glen!
10
Brooke R.
Aug 15, 2025
·
Stayed 8 nights
Amazing hosts, easy check in, thoughtful welcome wine and drinking water.
Amazing hosts, easy check in, thoughtful welcome wine and drinking water.
10
Keti M.
Sep 8, 2024
·
Stayed 5 nights
Host was very nice, and property was very beautiful. we enjoyed staying here and will be back for sure. Highly recommend.
Host was very nice, and property was very beautiful. we enjoyed staying here and will be back for sure. Highly recommend.
10
Brooke R.
Aug 16, 2024
·
Stayed 8 nights
Our recent stay at this home was amazing. So amazing that we requested an additional night and it was easily accommodated. The location of the home is perfect for visiting the many wineries along the lake and just a short ride to Seneca Lake. We spent most of our time fishing off the gorgeous dock catching yellow perch and my husband was even able to catch a lake trout from the kayaks on the property. Jennifer and Toby are top notch hosts who are very easy to communicate with and welcome you with a delicious bottle of wine upon arrival. We can not wait to hopefully book this home for our Finger Lakes getaway next year.
Our recent stay at this home was amazing. So amazing that we requested an additional night and it was easily accommodated. The location of the home is perfect for visiting the many wineries along the lake and just a short ride to Seneca Lake. We spent most of our time fishing off the gorgeous dock catching yellow perch and my husband was even able to catch a lake trout from the kayaks on the property. Jennifer and Toby are top notch hosts who are very easy to communicate with and welcome you with a delicious bottle of wine upon arrival. We can not wait to hopefully book this home for our Finger Lakes getaway next year.
10
Lisa W.
Sep 29, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
The lake cabin was so cute & cozy! Bed was SUPER comfortable from the time you got in it to the time you got up. The view is spectacular, can't get any better & the cabin has everything you need. Was great to have a fire and a glass wine by the lake & to listen to the waves coming in on the shore. Owner was great & readily available to answer any questions...I would highly recommend this wonderful & special lake cabin & we would definitely come back to stay again..
The lake cabin was so cute & cozy! Bed was SUPER comfortable from the time you got in it to the time you got up. The view is spectacular, can't get any better & the cabin has everything you need. Was great to have a fire and a glass wine by the lake & to listen to the waves coming in on the shore. Owner was great & readily available to answer any questions...I would highly recommend this wonderful & special lake cabin & we would definitely come back to stay again..
10
Jeannine L.
Sep 9, 2023
·
Stayed 5 nights
My husband and I stayed here for our honeymoon. We had such a great time! The cottage is so clean which was our first impression. We spent our week soaking up the sun right on the deck. The kayaks and stand up paddle board were a lot of fun to use and travel down the lake with. We grilled every night! And they have all the cooking essentials you will need. Jen was easy to get in contact with, we had a question about the lock on the door and she called us within a minute to answer our question. The last day we stopped at Taughannock Falls for a walk with our dog Remi and then we stopped at the Sheldrake Point Winery. We recommend both! The cottage was perfect for our dog and since it was all fenced in we didn’t have to worry about him getting out. All in all we had a wonderful time and would definitely book again!
My husband and I stayed here for our honeymoon. We had such a great time! The cottage is so clean which was our first impression. We spent our week soaking up the sun right on the deck. The kayaks and stand up paddle board were a lot of fun to use and travel down the lake with. We grilled every night! And they have all the cooking essentials you will need. Jen was easy to get in contact with, we had a question about the lock on the door and she called us within a minute to answer our question. The last day we stopped at Taughannock Falls for a walk with our dog Remi and then we stopped at the Sheldrake Point Winery. We recommend both! The cottage was perfect for our dog and since it was all fenced in we didn’t have to worry about him getting out. All in all we had a wonderful time and would definitely book again!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Location
Peaceful, right on Cayuga Lake with sunrise views, and convenient to wineries, hiking spots, Ithaca, and nearby Seneca Lake. Guests also mention a quiet neighborhood with restaurants and music venues within a short drive.
Related guest reviews
10
Peter S.
Jun 9, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Beautiful spot on the water. Kayaks were great, good fishing off the dock, nice grill and fenced in property for the dog. Couple good restaurants nearby and plenty of wineries - all around fantastic stay. We hope to be back soon!
Beautiful spot on the water. Kayaks were great, good fishing off the dock, nice grill and fenced in property for the dog. Couple good restaurants nearby and plenty of wineries - all around fantastic stay. We hope to be back soon!
10
James H.
Jun 28, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
Perfect location in the middle of the lake on the west side and right on the water! Property is well-kept and had all necessary amenities! Romantic getaway for a couple
Perfect location in the middle of the lake on the west side and right on the water! Property is well-kept and had all necessary amenities! Romantic getaway for a couple
10
Stacey D.
Oct 13, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
My husband and I had a very nice getaway at the cottage. It’s in the perfect location. Close to wineries and hiking. The cottage had everything we needed. Love to come again in the summer and enjoy the water.
My husband and I had a very nice getaway at the cottage. It’s in the perfect location. Close to wineries and hiking. The cottage had everything we needed. Love to come again in the summer and enjoy the water.
10
Diane R.
Jul 31, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
We had a great stay at this cute little cottage on the lake. Check in was seamless with all information provided well in advance. Well equipped kitchen as we ate in each night. We loved being on the water and enjoying the peaceful lake. The location was great for visiting both Seneca and Cayuga lakes. Highly recommend Taughannock Falls and Watkins Glen!
We had a great stay at this cute little cottage on the lake. Check in was seamless with all information provided well in advance. Well equipped kitchen as we ate in each night. We loved being on the water and enjoying the peaceful lake. The location was great for visiting both Seneca and Cayuga lakes. Highly recommend Taughannock Falls and Watkins Glen!
10
Geoffrey G.
Aug 1, 2023
·
Stayed 5 nights
Location was perfect, and cottage was exceptional. Would definitely recommend!!
Location was perfect, and cottage was exceptional. Would definitely recommend!!
10
Sara W.
Apr 16, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
My husband and I loved our time here at this cozy cottage. The location is amazing as it is close to wineries and hiking spots. We spent most of our time just relaxing on the deck listening to the water. It was truly a relaxing getaway.
My husband and I loved our time here at this cozy cottage. The location is amazing as it is close to wineries and hiking spots. We spent most of our time just relaxing on the deck listening to the water. It was truly a relaxing getaway.
10
Patricia N.
Jun 9, 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Lovely cottage! Lovely neighborhood close to most any place youd like to visit in the Finger Lakes!!
Lovely cottage! Lovely neighborhood close to most any place youd like to visit in the Finger Lakes!!
8
Sueanne P.
Aug 12, 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Very nice cottage right on the water. Quiet, peaceful and very clean. Everything you could need was available. There are many venues to hear all types of music within 15-20 miles in the afternoon and early evening.
Very nice cottage right on the water. Quiet, peaceful and very clean. Everything you could need was available. There are many venues to hear all types of music within 15-20 miles in the afternoon and early evening.
10
Jason G.
Oct 15, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Amazing gem of a cabin ideally located within distance to Ithaca, wineries and all the region has to offer. Always a wonderful stay for a fall weekend.
Amazing gem of a cabin ideally located within distance to Ithaca, wineries and all the region has to offer. Always a wonderful stay for a fall weekend.
10
Mike B.
Oct 26, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Perfect location on the lake where you could watch the sunrise every morning. Close to many wineries, hikes, and Ithaca. Perfect for anniversary getaway.
Perfect location on the lake where you could watch the sunrise every morning. Close to many wineries, hikes, and Ithaca. Perfect for anniversary getaway.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Dining
Not enough information in reviews.
Related guest reviews
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
10
Ann N.
Jun 29, 2026
·
Stayed 7 nights
Love this place!!
Love this place!!
10
Laura B.
Jun 20, 2026
·
Stayed 4 nights
The house was amazing and very comfortable. The property was beautiful with great lake views and access. I would definitely stay here again with my family.
The house was amazing and very comfortable. The property was beautiful with great lake views and access. I would definitely stay here again with my family.
10
Tammy B.
May 7, 2026
·
Stayed 3 nights
Had a great weekend at the wine and herb fest with family. There was 6 adults and enough room for us and more. The house was located perfectly to visit all of the wineries on the west side. We had a beautiful view of the lake but a little cold to enjoy it sadly. We had all we needed there and Tristan was quick to respond with any questions we had. Would definitely stay again and recommend to others.
Had a great weekend at the wine and herb fest with family. There was 6 adults and enough room for us and more. The house was located perfectly to visit all of the wineries on the west side. We had a beautiful view of the lake but a little cold to enjoy it sadly. We had all we needed there and Tristan was quick to respond with any questions we had. Would definitely stay again and recommend to others.
10
Ann N.
Jul 30, 2025
·
Stayed 7 nights
Casa Cayuga is a lovely house with a large yard for pets to run in and kids young and old to safely play.
Casa Cayuga is a lovely house with a large yard for pets to run in and kids young and old to safely play.
10
Brian G.
Jul 21, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Excellent stay, as always. We've been coming here for several years now and the house, property, and location never disappoint!
Excellent stay, as always. We've been coming here for several years now and the house, property, and location never disappoint!
Property Policies
Check-in
Check-out
Check-in from 16:00
Before 10:00
FAQs about Charming 4-Season Cayuga Lake House near Sheldrake Point!!
Are pets allowed at the property?
Pets are allowed, with a maximum of three dogs permitted. Service animals are exempt from any pet restrictions. Guests are requested to pick up after their pets.
What is the location of the property in relation to key landmarks?
The property is located on the waterfront in Interlaken, New York, near Cayuga Lake and Taughannock Falls State Park. It is situated in the center of New York State's wine country and is approximately 25 minutes north of Ithaca, NY, and the Cornell University campus.
What are the policies for guests staying with children?
Children are permitted at the property, and ages 0-17 can stay for free.
Have a question?
Instant AI responses are based on hotel information
Popular amenities
Pet Friendly
Refrigerator
TV
Microwave
Hair Dryer
DVD Player
Activities
Garden
Fishing
Bird Watching
Kayaking
Hiking
Water-skiing
Books
Firepit
Mountain Bike (nearby)
Public Winery Tours
Video Library
Services
Laundry Facilities
Internet
Free Wi-Fi
General
Pet Friendly
Refrigerator
Microwave
Hair Dryer
TV
DVD Player
Desk
Towels
Smoke-Free Property
Upper Floors (Stairs Only)
Parking
Electric Car charging station
Dock