Shelter Island Retreat w/ Outdoor Pool!
From
$1,423
/ night
Select dates to see prices and availability
From
$1,423
/ night
About this property
Take advantage of recreation opportunities such as an outdoor pool, or other amenities including complimentary wireless internet access and an arcade/game room.
Location
78 S Ram Island Dr
Menhadden Lane Beach (2 miles)
Shelter Island Whale's Tail (4 miles)
Havens House (4.7 miles)
Shelter Island Historical Society (4.7 miles)
Gardiner's Bay Country Club (4.9 miles)
Shelter Island Country Club (5.3 miles)
Room options
45
House (5 Bedrooms)
Room details
3× King Beds
, 1 Queen Bed
, and 6× Twin Beds
Sleeps 8
4994 ft²
BalconyAir ConditioningHeatingWi-Fi (Free)Fireplace
Guest reviews of Shelter Island Retreat w/ Outdoor Pool!
9
Superb
Based on 10 verified reviews
10
Ed D.
Jun 26, 2026
·
Stayed 3 nights
This house was amazing. Exactly as pictured no surprises. Extremely clean inside. Very comfortable, beds were great. A lot of space. Host was very easy to contact, very responsive and friendly. Bright, a lot of natural light. Easy kitchen, a lot of refrigerator and freezer space. Pool and pool area was terrific. Excellent pool for swimming or lounging in the pool. Pool was cleaned during our stay. Definitely recommended for stay on Shelter Island. Gorgeous view of the water. Quiet area. You will not be disappointed. Two opportunities, sweep and clean pool deck and furniture before guest arrival, may suggest replacing some pots and pans.
This house was amazing. Exactly as pictured no surprises. Extremely clean inside. Very comfortable, beds were great. A lot of space. Host was very easy to contact, very responsive and friendly. Bright, a lot of natural light. Easy kitchen, a lot of refrigerator and freezer space. Pool and pool area was terrific. Excellent pool for swimming or lounging in the pool. Pool was cleaned during our stay. Definitely recommended for stay on Shelter Island. Gorgeous view of the water. Quiet area. You will not be disappointed. Two opportunities, sweep and clean pool deck and furniture before guest arrival, may suggest replacing some pots and pans.
10
craig h.
Sep 9, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Wonderful home in a gorgeous location.
Wonderful home in a gorgeous location.
10
Elizabeth P.
Jun 6, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Lovely house with great accommodations. Any questions we had were quickly answered. Perfect location - beautiful views from the decks. Look forward to returning!
Lovely house with great accommodations. Any questions we had were quickly answered. Perfect location - beautiful views from the decks. Look forward to returning!
10
Sara
Oct 7, 2024
·
8 of us old college friends stayed here for 3 nights for our annual reunion. This property on Shelter Island provided everything we might need, and exceeded our expectations. The beds were comfortable. The showers were hot. There were ensuite bathrooms for each bedroom. The kitchen was large and had every utensil needed to cook and serve a group. The dining table accommodated everyone. The living room had a large sectional for relaxing. But the best part was the view, the patio, and the proximity to a gorgeous rocky beach. We sat around and admired the view of the ocean, played bocce (provided with the property), and walked on the beach. It was perfect.
8 of us old college friends stayed here for 3 nights for our annual reunion. This property on Shelter Island provided everything we might need, and exceeded our expectations. The beds were comfortable. The showers were hot. There were ensuite bathrooms for each bedroom. The kitchen was large and had every utensil needed to cook and serve a group. The dining table accommodated everyone. The living room had a large sectional for relaxing. But the best part was the view, the patio, and the proximity to a gorgeous rocky beach. We sat around and admired the view of the ocean, played bocce (provided with the property), and walked on the beach. It was perfect.
10
Lauren R.
Sep 9, 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
My family and I had a wonderful stay at this gorgeous property. The pool is terrific, the view is amazing, and the layout was perfect for our large family so we could all have our own spaces and bathrooms. We loved it.
My family and I had a wonderful stay at this gorgeous property. The pool is terrific, the view is amazing, and the layout was perfect for our large family so we could all have our own spaces and bathrooms. We loved it.
FAQs about Shelter Island Retreat w/ Outdoor Pool!
Is parking available at the property?
Yes, free parking is available on-site.
Are pets allowed at the property?
No pets are allowed at this property.
What are the check-in and check-out times?
Check-in is from 3:00 PM and check-out is by 10:00 AM. Early or late check-in/check-out may be available upon request.
What is the location of the property in relation to nearby attractions?
The property is located in Shelter Island, 4 minutes from Menhadden Lane Beach and 8 minutes from Shelter Island Whale's Tail. It is also 6.7 miles from The Hamptons Beaches.
Does the property have a swimming pool?
Yes, there is an outdoor swimming pool available for guests.
What are the policies for guests staying with children?
Children are allowed at the property, and ages 0-17 can stay for free.
Have a question?
Instant AI responses are based on hotel information