Go back to search

Ruschmeyers Hotel

$278
/ night

Avg. for October

Ruschmeyers Hotel - Image 1
Ruschmeyers Hotel - Room
Ruschmeyers Hotel - Room
Ruschmeyers Hotel - Bathroom
Ruschmeyers Hotel - Room

Prices for Ruschmeyers Hotel

Select dates to see prices and availability

$278
/ night

Avg. for October

Monthly average prices

Nightly prices at Ruschmeyers Hotel average $278 in October, the cheapest month, and $518 in July, the most expensive, based on the last 12 months.

Average nightly price at Ruschmeyers Hotel by month, last 12 months (USD)
MonthAverage price
May$312
June$342
July$518
August$429
September$320
October$278

Most expensive: July (~$518)

Cheapest: October (~$278)

About this property

Make use of convenient amenities such as complimentary wireless internet access, a picnic area, and bike parking.
Show more
  • Parking

  • Non-Smoking Rooms

  • Housekeeping

  • Bicycle Rental

  • Garden

  • Golf Course (nearby)

Show all

Location

161 2nd House Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America

Fort Pond (0.1 miles)

Fort Pond Bay Beach (0.3 miles)

The Hamptons Beaches (0.3 miles)

Second House Museum (0.8 miles)

Kirk Park Beach (1 miles)

Navy Road Park (1.1 miles)


Room options

Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed

Room details

1 King Bed

Sleeps 2

Balcony
Air Conditioning
Heating
Wi-Fi (Free)
Fence Around Yard

Standard Room, 1 Queen Bed

Room details

1 Queen Bed

Sleeps 2

Balcony
Air Conditioning
Heating
Wi-Fi (Free)
Fence Around Yard

Deluxe Room, 1 Queen Bed

Room details

1 Queen Bed

Sleeps 2

Balcony
Air Conditioning
Heating
Wi-Fi (Free)
Fence Around Yard

Standard Room, 1 King Bed

Room details

1 King Bed

Sleeps 2

Balcony
Air Conditioning
Heating
Wi-Fi (Free)
Fence Around Yard

Deluxe Room, 2 Queen Beds

Room details

2 Queen Beds

Sleeps 4

Balcony
Air Conditioning
Heating
Wi-Fi (Free)
Fence Around Yard
1 King Bed
,
1 Twin Bed
, and
1 Bunk Bed

Sleeps 5

Balcony
Air Conditioning
Heating
Wi-Fi (Free)
Fence Around Yard

Guest reviews of Ruschmeyers Hotel

What guests think

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

At Ruschmeyers, travellers describe a lively, camp-style property with an on-site restaurant and bar, inviting outdoor spaces, and a convenient Montauk location, though overall impressions range from delighted to disappointed depending on the room and the stay.

Read more

Facilities

Lively

Cleanliness

Mixed

Rooms

Mixed

Location

Convenient

Dining

Enjoyable

Was this helpful?

4

Felicia

IAN-logo

Aug 16, 2026

·

Stayed 1 night

I would not recommend staying here - the overall vibe is sketchy. The check in was at the hostess stand of what was supposed to be the restaurant; however, the restaurant and bar are closed and not open for the season - which would have been helpful to have known before booking. Check in was strange - we just got a code to the room which was given off of the employees phone. The code ended up not working so they had to make a call to someone to fix it. Overall, it was eerily quiet - barely anyone around I’m assuming since the restaurant and bar are not open for the season. There was an outdoor seating area with bean bag chairs which was overrun and unusable. There were no employees to be found if you needed help - there was only a sign on the door with a phone number to call. The room we booked was a “king suite” which was marketed as there being a separate bedroom area - which there certainly was not. It was a tiny room and the bathroom was very small. The walls are paper thin - we could hear our neighbors conversations. And on top of that it’s a trek into town. Overall, it was disappointing to say the least. If the restaurant and bar were not going to be open this season they should have been upfront with that upon booking and also it shouldn’t have been so expensive.
I would not recommend staying here - the overall vibe is sketchy. The check in was at the hostess stand of what was supposed to be the restaurant; however, the restaurant and bar are closed and not open for the season - which would have been helpful to have known before booking. Check in was strange - we just got a code to the room which was given off of the employees phone. The code ended up not working so they had to make a call to someone to fix it. Overall, it was eerily quiet - barely anyone around I’m assuming since the restaurant and bar are not open for the season. There was an outdoor seating area with bean bag chairs which was overrun and unusable. There were no employees to be found if you needed help - there was only a sign on the door with a phone number to call. The room we booked was a “king suite” which was marketed as there being a separate bedroom area - which there certainly was not. It was a tiny room and the bathroom was very small. The walls are paper thin - we could hear our neighbors conversations. And on top of that it’s a trek into town. Overall, it was disappointing to say the least. If the restaurant and bar were not going to be open this season they should have been upfront with that upon booking and also it shouldn’t have been so expensive.

4

Dan

IAN-logo

Aug 10, 2026

·

Stayed 2 nights

The place is basically shut down. Everything is locked up and there is no staff except the cleaning crew. You should just go camping instead.
The place is basically shut down. Everything is locked up and there is no staff except the cleaning crew. You should just go camping instead.

6

Benjamin

IAN-logo

Jul 25, 2026

·

Stayed 2 nights

Staff was really nice but none of the advertised amenities were available. The first room we were put in smelled like sewage and had big cobwebs so the woman working very helpfully had us move to a new room and that room had long hairs on the wall and floor. So I cleaned that up. For the money, I’ll stay somewhere else next time. Was hoping for a much better experience.
Staff was really nice but none of the advertised amenities were available. The first room we were put in smelled like sewage and had big cobwebs so the woman working very helpfully had us move to a new room and that room had long hairs on the wall and floor. So I cleaned that up. For the money, I’ll stay somewhere else next time. Was hoping for a much better experience.

6

Juan

IAN-logo

Jul 17, 2026

·

Stayed 3 nights

The property is not as advertised. The restaurant and bar is closed indefinitely. There’s a nice courtyard in the middle to hang out at but there is barely any staff around to get the fire pits turned on. There is no front desk and if you cannot get a hold of anyone, you’re kind of screwed. This property has so much potential and just a year ago they had a big grand opening with all the amenities available but have no idea what happened from then to now. We’re visiting in peak season and the place seemed like a ghost town. The one silver lining was the cleaning staff. The lady was extremely nice and friendly.
The property is not as advertised. The restaurant and bar is closed indefinitely. There’s a nice courtyard in the middle to hang out at but there is barely any staff around to get the fire pits turned on. There is no front desk and if you cannot get a hold of anyone, you’re kind of screwed. This property has so much potential and just a year ago they had a big grand opening with all the amenities available but have no idea what happened from then to now. We’re visiting in peak season and the place seemed like a ghost town. The one silver lining was the cleaning staff. The lady was extremely nice and friendly.

6

Lisa

EXP-logo

Jun 29, 2026

·

Stayed 1 night

This property is a very cute cabin community with decent rooms and very comfortable beds. The room was clean and the bathroom was fairly reasonable as well (a bit small but nice shower). The grounds are beautiful and the location is great. The downside is the staff is not very helpful and didn't provide the information requested. They were also unreachable to get the wifi password so no wifi for us during our stay! All the facilities including the restaurant and bar were closed. When we asked about it the first answer was "open seasonally". Since it was late June I asked what season if not summer!! Then the answer changed to "we are renovating" but no evidence of such activity! So if you want a place to just sleep, then this is a good place and relatively reasonably priced (still "spendy" for what it is)...
This property is a very cute cabin community with decent rooms and very comfortable beds. The room was clean and the bathroom was fairly reasonable as well (a bit small but nice shower). The grounds are beautiful and the location is great. The downside is the staff is not very helpful and didn't provide the information requested. They were also unreachable to get the wifi password so no wifi for us during our stay! All the facilities including the restaurant and bar were closed. When we asked about it the first answer was "open seasonally". Since it was late June I asked what season if not summer!! Then the answer changed to "we are renovating" but no evidence of such activity! So if you want a place to just sleep, then this is a good place and relatively reasonably priced (still "spendy" for what it is)...

Property Policies

Check-in instructions

Everything you need to know for a smooth check-in.

Show more

Check-in

Check-out

From 16:00 to 23:59

Before 11:00


Good to know

Additional policies and info about this property.

Show more

FAQs about Ruschmeyers Hotel

Is parking available at the property?

Free self-parking is available on-site.


Is breakfast offered at the hotel?

Breakfast is available at Placēbō Restaurant, which serves a satisfying meal for guests.


What are the check-in and check-out times?

Check-in is from 4:00 PM to 11:59 PM, and check-out is by 11:00 AM. Early or late check-in/check-out may be available upon request.

What is the hotel's location in relation to nearby attractions?

The property is located just a 1-minute walk from Fort Pond and 6 minutes by foot from Fort Pond Bay Beach. It is also 0.3 miles from The Hamptons Beaches and 0.7 miles from Navy Park Road.


What are the policies regarding children at the hotel?

Children are allowed at the property, and the minimum age for children to stay for free is not specified.


Have a question?

Instant AI responses are based on hotel information


Prices for upcoming dates

October 2026
November 2026

Cheaper

Pricier

Average nightly price across deals, with taxes & fees.

Prices in USD for 2 guests, updated daily.



  • Montauk Yacht Club
  • Montauk Manor
  • Montauk Blue Hotel
  • Kenny's Tipperary Inn
  • Daunts Albatross Motel
  • Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
  • Breakers Montauk
  • The Montauk Soundview

Product

  • Affiliate program
  • Cookie preferences
  • Cookie policy
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of use

Social


© 2026 Vio